The Gift, Necessity, and Complexity of Forgiveness
The Gift, Necessity, and Complexity of Forgiveness
Forgiveness is a funny topic in the Christian life. Not funny “haha,” but funny in the “hard to get your mind around it” kind of way. Secular frameworks misunderstand and misuse the concept of forgiveness. Christians often make opposite but equally devastating errors: either not taking it seriously or oversimplifying it. In this brief post, we’ll unpack how and why that is, then look at a profound passage in Matthew 18:21-35 to see what God reveals about why we must forgive and what can give us the strength to see it through.
Secular Views
Forgiveness is a subject that secular folks can talk about, but it nearly always lacks anything resembling biblical depth, and is usually touted as something good solely because of its benefit to the one who was wronged – not because it is also good for the wrongdoer, their relationship, or the wider community. If it were put into words, this kind of thinking might sound something like, “I’m not holding your wrong against you, because to do so would weigh me down and cause me continued mental and emotional harm.” No doubt there are God-given benefits to the forgiver, but this isn’t fundamentally why Christians are called to forgive. Do you see how, left to itself, this would be a manipulative means to an end, rather than an act of glad-hearted obedience to Christ?
Perhaps more commonly, a secular mindset struggles to even have a category of forgiveness in the first place. Why would it? If there is no powerful and personal God who will one day carry out justice, then it is up to you and me to carry it out ourselves, vigilante-style if necessary. Even more specifically, if there is no God who is as loving as he is holy, then the story of the Creator coming to earth as the God-Man to willingly die for the sins of humanity will fail to melt hearts. There will be no category for forgiveness, because there is no true Story of forgiveness being offered to humans who require it in the first place.
Common Christian Misconceptions
Even Christians, who objectively believe in forgiveness – indeed, whose entire faith is grounded on it – often fail to properly understand and apply it. One common error is not taking it seriously enough. Oh, in terms of formal belief, we might say all the right things about forgiveness. But the moment that a boss or a spouse or an in-law says or does something (real or perceived) against us, forgiveness goes out the window. In Mere Christianity, C.S. Lewis said, "Everyone says forgiveness is a lovely idea, until they have something to forgive.”
Another common error goes the opposite direction, namely, failing to recognize and appreciate the complexities of forgiveness. I think this often occurs not when we are the ones wronged, but when we are evaluating the situations of others who are wronged. We are prone to making forgiveness one-dimensional, simple, and lacking nuance. We say (or at least think) things like: “To forgive means you should forget”; “That person who hurt you said they were sorry, so you should let it go and be friends with them again”; “Not going back to how things used to be shows that you must be hanging on to bitterness.” Forgiveness is not always so easy, and the Bible doesn’t pretend that it is.
One analogy I’ve come across that I believe makes sense is that forgiveness is like a loan.1 If I give a financial loan to someone and they misuse it and are therefore unable to pay any of it back, my response is likely a predictable one. Hopefully, I will forgive him or her – i.e., not leverage their foolishness against them in a weaponized fashion – but I would be unwise indeed to immediately give them another loan, no matter how sorry they said they were. Not giving them another loan can absolutely coexist with the choice to forgive them. To say that forgiveness requires that I ignore their track record – that I pay no attention to their poor decisions – is foolishness. When someone wrongs me intentionally or repeatedly, they have essentially misused the loan of trust that I’ve given them. I can (must!) forgive them, but I would be naïve to give them another loan of trust immediately without first seeing some fruit of consistent repentance. Hopefully, this analogy makes the point simply and effectively that forgiveness sometimes demands refinement in how we think about it.
Matthew 18:21-35
Jesus tells a story in this passage, and the story is a crafted response to Peter’s question about how often he should forgive someone who sins against him. Peter (perhaps proudly) suggests as many as seven times. Seven often signifies completion and perfection in the Bible. In other words, Peter likely thought his response would impress Jesus. Shockingly, Jesus responds with, “No, not seven times, but seventy times seven!” (v. 22) He isn’t meaning this literally (i.e., 490 times). Whatever else he means, he is multiplying “perfection” by a large number. In other words, Jesus is saying the number of times we should forgive others is infinite.
Jesus then tells the story of a servant who owed a king ten thousand talents. A talent was the highest level of currency in the Roman world.2 By any standard of measurement – labor or monetary value – this debtor was literally never going to be able to pay off the debt to the king. In terms of labor, one talent equaled roughly twenty years of work for a common laborer. Do the math. Ten thousand talents equaled 200,000 years of labor. In terms of actual monetary value, it’s unknown exactly how much ten thousand talents is equal to today, but it is likely in the hundreds of millions (if not billions) of dollars. Either way, the debtor servant’s plea to the king, “Please, be patient with me, and I will pay it all” (v. 26), is ridiculously pitiful. He has no chance, but desperation prompts us to say and do things we know are not based in reality. It’s not going to happen. It’s impossible. The king responds in a way that defies imagination. “Then his master was filled with pity for him, and he released him and forgave his debt.” (v. 27) This is incredible. No one forced the king to do this. The servant was at the mercy of whatever was the substance of the king’s heart and character. Furthermore, for the king to waive this debt meant he did so at great expense to his kingdom. It wasn’t just “nice.” It came at great cost to himself.
Immediately after this forgiven servant leaves the presence of the king, he finds a fellow servant who owed him one hundred denarii. In ancient times, one denarius was worth a day’s wages. In other words, the forgiven servant was owed the equivalent of three or four months’ wages by his fellow servant. In today’s economics, we might say this could be in the neighborhood of $12,000-$15,000. Not insignificant, but nothing compared to what the first servant owed the king. Unbelievably, when this second servant asks for the same kind of mercy the first servant had received from the king, the first servant refuses. He had his fellow servant arrested and thrown into prison until he could repay the debt (v. 30).
There is so much that could be said about this parable. It is profound, serious, and emotionally provocative. But we’ll settle for two things here that connect to the Christian misconceptions of forgiveness discussed earlier. First, to be wronged in such a way that the monetary parallel would be to lose $12,000-$15,000 is no small thing. To lose that amount would change the average person’s life, at least in the short run. It would be incredibly painful and more than a mere inconvenience. Unfortunately, many Christians act as if forgiveness should be easy, and they treat wounded Christians this way. They speak tritely of sin, pain, and forgiveness. They forget that forgiveness nearly always implies pain. We should be very aware of this and never minimize the sincere suffering experienced by others.
Second, while it is true that forgiving others is often incredibly agonizing – after all, it is unnatural – it is absolutely what Christians are commanded to do. We have been forgiven by God a debt we could never repay, and it came at the cost of Jesus’s life. If we think our sin is not that bad, then we don’t get it. As just one thought experiment, would you want your life to be recorded on camera for 24 hours and broadcast to the world? What about your thoughts from the last 24 hours being broadcast to the public?
If someone has been sinned against and refuses to forgive, there is reason to wonder whether they have truly experienced and appreciated God’s forgiveness through Jesus. Notice I am not saying this is always easy. Forgiveness is often labor. It is most fundamentally a decision, not a feeling. But a person who has truly been forgiven their sin by God will at least be “facing” the right direction. They will want to want to forgive as they have been forgiven. This is because they know that, however much someone has wronged them, it pales in comparison to the gravity of their own sin against their Maker.
Let us commit to never forgetting the grace shown to us by Christ. He is both our model and the motive for our forgiveness to others. “Be kind to each other, tenderhearted, forgiving one another, just as God through Christ has forgiven you.” (Eph. 4:32) We don’t forgive in our own power or for just our own benefit. The whole basis is that we are the servants of the King, deserving of eternal separation, and yet were lavishly and freely freed of our debt. The servant in the parable incredulously was unchanged by the king’s grace. You and I – let’s commit together to allow the King’s generous grace to soften our hearts and flow out to those who need that grace as well.
Notes
1 I borrow this metaphor from biblical counselor Brad Hambrick in his book Making Sense of Forgiveness.
2Tim Keller, Forgive: Why Should I and How Can I?, chapter 1. Keller suggests the numerical figures and estimations mentioned here. He also makes the insight that for the king to forgive this servant’s debt not only was an incredible gift to the servant, but came at the expense of his own kingdom.

















