Does “Turn the Other Cheek” Mean God Wants Me to Be a Pushover?
Does “Turn the Other Cheek” Mean God Wants Me to Be a Pushover?
I was recently involved in a conversation where someone asked, “What does it mean to ‘turn the other cheek’?” This led to a personal task of organizing my thoughts around what this verse (Matt. 5:39) and other similar biblical passages mean. First, let’s unpack Matt. 5:39 in its context, and then also look at a few other passages that shed additional light on this subject.
In Matthew 5-7, Jesus is teaching crowds who have gathered around him. This section of Scripture is known as the Sermon on the Mount. It is a remarkable section, one that we can’t speak to broadly here. But as we zoom in specifically on 5:38-39, Jesus says, “You have heard the law that says the punishment must match the injury: ‘An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth.’ But I say, do not resist an evil person! If someone slaps you on the right cheek, offer the other cheek also.” What can “do not resist an evil person” and “offer the other cheek also” mean? It may first help to know what it can’t mean. First, this verse can’t be rightly applied in every scenario, including the following ones:
- Parenting – Eph. 6:1-4
- Government/military – Rom. 13:1-4; Luke 3:14
- Schools/teachers – this is an extension of rightful authority having its place; authority cannot afford to “turn the other cheek” to students in every possible way.
- Businesses/employers – bosses and company owners have standards that need to be upheld by those working under them; it is not kind to fail to maintain these standards when it comes to an unethical or lazy employee
Furthermore, whatever Jesus does mean, he clearly cannot mean for us to be “walked all over” and passively let evil have its way. If we let Romans 12:21 (“Don’t let evil conquer you, but conquer evil by doing good.”) speak to this passage, we have to say that Jesus is not getting at the idea of letting evil win, but of somehow overcoming evil through doing good. As Matt Perman says, “We have all seen the wisdom of Jesus’ words here in our everyday lives. Much of the time, the most effective way to overcome evil is by not resisting. If someone says a mean word, it is far more effective to respond with kindness than with another mean word in return. If someone tries wrongly to cut you off on the freeway, it is usually best just to let them do it.”
But still the confusion may persist – even if Jesus isn’t saying to passively let evil win (and he’s not), is he saying that the only way to defeat evil is by responding with overt kindness and that more forceful means of defense or seeking protection are wrong?
At this point, it’s important to keep in mind who he is speaking to in this section of Matthew. He is speaking to regular people (private citizens). He is not speaking to or about agents of the government in this section of his teaching. Also, keep in mind that in the Sermon on the Mount, Jesus seems to at times be using hyperbole. It’s doubtful that he literally means we should:
- Gouge out our eyes or cut off our hands (5:29-30)
- Always and only pray if we are alone (6:6)
On the contrary, says Matt Perman, “Jesus is using hyperbole to illustrate what our primary disposition and attitude should be, not to say that we should literally give in to every attempt to do evil against us.”
Other related passages:
Matthew 7:1-6
- This section is also part of Jesus’ teaching on the Sermon on the Mount. So we should expect there to be harmony in what he says from chapter 5 to chapter 7. Any apparent discrepancy between them simply means we need to do the hard work of trying to understand what is meant.
- When we hear this passage referenced, usually it leaves off verse 6, which says, “Don’t waste what is holy on people who are unholy. Don’t throw your pearls to pigs! They will trample the pearls, then turn and attack you.” To be fair, at first glance, verse 6 seems to be in an awkward “no man’s land,” stuck on an island between 7:1-5 and 7:7-11. But it clearly does not seem to go as neatly with verses 7-11.
- It makes sense to read 7:1-5 through the grid of relationships that go from more distant to more connected. For example, the first two verses could apply to people we are aware of, but not closely tied to (e.g., frustrating acquaintances, individuals whose poor decisions we see on the news, the podcaster whose rants drive us crazy, etc.). With these individuals, we try to give the benefit of the doubt and “let love cover a multitude of sins” (Prov. 19:11). Verses 3-4 seem to potentially bring the impact of someone’s actions a bit closer. These are people we know well (e.g., friends, family members, neighbors, fellow church members, etc.). In these cases, their offenses hurt us more and we are not as easily able to simply remove ourselves from the damage inflicted by their actions. In these situations, we may indeed need to confront them, but we don’t want to be hypocritical about it (which is why we need to first examine ourselves).
- By the time we get to verse 6, Jesus may be speaking to scenarios in which a person has faithfully tried everything they can think of to be kind and live peaceably (Rom. 12:18), but the other person won’t have it, and their actions continue in some manner to be malicious, vitriolic, and mean. Our good intentions and actions are not being reciprocated. In this case, Jesus says to no longer “throw pearls before pigs.”
John 10:18
- Jesus said he voluntarily laid down his life; it was not taken from him. Pastor Chris Nye points out, “[T]here is a difference between laying your life down and someone taking it.” Additionally, when we come to verses like Matt. 16:24 and 1 John 3:16 that instruct us to turn away from selfishness and lay down our lives for others, “notice the active agent…you. There is a difference between voluntarily laying down your life and someone taking your life from you.”
Rom. 12:17-13:5
- The end of Rom. 12 appears to have both intrapersonal and interpersonal angles (don’t harbor vengeful desires, seek to live at peace with all).
- Don’t be misled by inserted chapter divisions. Biblical counselor Brad Hambrick states, “There was only a dip of [Paul’s] writing quill between Romans 12:21 and Romans 13:1.”
- Hambrick goes on to say, “My concern is that most Christians are more familiar with Romans 12 when it comes to conflict, and miss the application of Romans 13 when conflict transitions from a personal offense to a legal offense. We read Romans 12 and think of harsh interpersonal conflict. We read Romans 13 and think about obeying speed limits and paying our taxes.”
- The beginning of Rom. 13 is about submitting to governing authorities, who should have the authority and processes in place to render justice.
- One way to summarize Rom. 12:17-13:5, says Hambrick, is, “It means a battered wife can get a restraining order without violating Romans 12. It means it is not unforgiving or punitive for Christians to call Child Protective Services if they suspect a child is being harmed or neglected.”
The instinct to “turn the other cheek” to individuals who may be doing us harm (at modest levels or even at more serious, life-threatening levels) makes sense. After all, we are called to follow in the footsteps of Jesus, who gave of himself in life and death for others. And we know that in life we will have suffering. All of this is true at the personal level. But at another level, it does not follow that God intends for individuals to be harmed in a malicious, physical, or ongoing way when it is in the power of civil authorities to prevent that harm and exact justice for the good of the wrongdoer and the one being hurt.
Some of us who have a “don’t walk on me” mentality need to take Matthew 5:39 to heart. We need to lean hard away from our tendency to rise up indignantly when faced with opposition. After all, it is the kindness of God that leads to repentance (Rom. 2:4). For many, the kindness of God will be expressed through your gracious and patient putting up with them. Many of us are far too trigger-happy to let others have it; we don’t suffer fools well, in the process showing ourselves to be the fool. We show that we don't take the warning of suffering in Scripture seriously, or we label inconvenience as suffering far too easily (or both). But God also doesn’t desire people to be physically hurt or in some other way assailed by lawbreakers and perpetrators. That is where the proper role of government comes in (e.g., Romans 13). God cares about personal interactions that cross over into civil and criminal offenses, and he makes provision for handling these situations. He also cares about how we interact with more garden-variety or bitter personal offenses, and this is likely closer to the realm of Matthew 5:39 and “Turn the other cheek.”
















